You can’t Fight City Hall

Wilmington Island Garden Club and allies protest the destruction of 2 mature live oaks by Chatham County, Georgia. The oaks are the first two in a glorious, mile-long canopy of live oaks, each more than 100 years old, that meet over Johnny Mercer Blvd. on Wilmington Island. At the zoning hearing for this site’s development, the site plan showed that the oaks would not be harmed, and all seemed well until a notice of traffic disruption to fell the trees appeared in the paper.
The police, standing dangerously in the road, are arguing with the protesters. About a dozen armed policemen confronting about 15 little old ladies in tennis shoes looked pretty silly, as you can imagine.
The police said, “Move.”
We said, “We’re on a public right-of-way, not private property, and we won’t move.”
Possibly because 2 television cameras were rolling, the police drifted indecisively away to the other side of the road. All this took place at a fairly major intersection with traffic lights. The miracle is that nobody was killed. The inattentive driving as people peered to read the signs and then honked and waved encouragement was a sight to behold. We certainly have the support of the islanders.
One contractor stopped by to chat and told us how contractors and developers circumvent the zoning laws and ordinances of the Chatham County Commission. No surprise, because it’s exactly the same method we civilians use: show the planning board an acceptable plan, get it approved, and then do exactly what you want because never, in the 20+ years I have lived on the island has the county ever enforced building codes, zoning laws, sign ordinances, etc. It doesn’t matter how many rules and regulations you promulgate, if no one enforces them, you might as well not have them.
We stayed until the tree-cutting permit expired, which means the trees are still standing, although not, I imagine for long.
I told a colleague what we were planning and he said, “Oh Bobby Chu owns that property, doesn’t he? In that case, you’re toast. He’s a big contributor to the county commissioners.” As if I didn’t know it.
We got great coverage on 3 TV stations and in the newspaper (with photo) and the Wilmington Island Garden Club gained a little stature in the community, but I’ll bet the trees are toast.
Next day, here are Garden Club members tending some of the 135 live oaks and crape myrtles we planted on Johnny Mercer lo these many years ago. These were to beautify the island for the Olympics. In exchange for the thousands of dollars and hours of volunteer labor we put into this, the county promised that it would complete the bike paths around the island. 12 years later, I need hardly say that the bike paths are incomplete. The only thing the county has planted on the island in the last 25 years is half a dozen hollies, which they put in the wrong place and which are now merely dead or nearly dead.
Ah me, what can you say? The rich get richer and we the people get screwed.


I lived in the Low Country for several years, and the live oaks were like old friends — each with its own character. It was devastating to see what Hugo did to them in 89.
Fight the good fight, your cause is right.
Comment by Les — March 27, 2008 @ 9:05 pm
Good Luck! I have my eye on an ebony tree designated as “historic” my my town’s landscaping ordinance - that is in the path of a planned road. I just may embarrass my children over that tree!
Comment by Mary Beth — March 27, 2008 @ 9:48 pm
Thank you, Les.
Mary Beth: I think I’ve been chicken for most of my life and I’ve decided it’s time to stand up and embarrass my children–which is an excellent way to express it. Turns out of course, they may hide their faces for a minute, but they are actually proud of an activist Mum. My son, helped us plant some of the live oaks–although that’s not particularly embarrassing.
Comment by karen — March 28, 2008 @ 6:48 am
What you’re doing is right, and it can feel very lonely standing up to your council because almost nobody cares, but trees are a good habitat for creatures and they’re beautiful too and this makes a real big difference to how comfortable we feel in our own neighbourhoods. You’re an inspiration.
Simon
Comment by Simon Kirby — March 28, 2008 @ 1:11 pm
Savannahians are quite well-educated about trees, oddly enough. Ecosystem services roll off their tongues. In summer it is 15 degrees (F) cooler under a live oak than under a porch. The trees wick water out of a swampy area that lies right behind them, they gulp up carbon dioxide (although younger ones do that more efficiently). Passers by honked and cheered, and the local paper penned an impassioned editorial. But you are right that no one will do anything about it.
Comment by karen — March 29, 2008 @ 7:32 am